Buyer's Guide: Wood Burning vs. Propane Fire Pits

Choosing the right fire pit can make all the difference in your outdoor experience. Whether you're drawn to the crackling ambiance of a wood fire or the convenience of propane, this guide breaks down everything you need to know to make the best choice for your backyard.

Wood Burning Fire Pits

The Experience

Wood burning fire pits deliver the classic, authentic campfire experience. The sound of crackling wood, the smell of smoke, and the dancing flames create an atmosphere that's hard to replicate. If ambiance is your top priority, wood burning is tough to beat.

Pros

• Authentic atmosphere – Real wood fire with natural crackling sounds and aroma
• Higher heat output – Wood fires typically burn hotter, great for colder nights
• No fuel hookup needed – Just add wood; no gas lines or propane tanks required
• Lower upfront cost – Wood burning fire pits are generally less expensive to purchase
• Portable – No need to stay near a gas source

Cons

• Requires wood supply – You'll need to store and replenish firewood
• Produces smoke and ash – Requires regular cleaning and can be irritating in windy conditions
• Less control – Harder to adjust flame size or turn off quickly
• Restricted in some areas – Local burn bans or HOA rules may limit use
• Longer startup time – Building and lighting a fire takes more effort

Propane Fire Pits

The Experience

Propane fire pits offer unmatched convenience and a clean, consistent flame. With the turn of a knob, you have instant fire — no kindling, no smoke, no mess. They're ideal for homeowners who want a low-maintenance outdoor feature.

Pros

• Instant on/off – Light and extinguish with the turn of a knob
• Adjustable flame – Easily control the size and intensity of the fire
• Clean burning – No smoke, ash, or embers to deal with
• Safe for more spaces – Often allowed in areas where wood burning is restricted
• Low maintenance – No ash cleanup; just replace or refill the propane tank

Cons

• Ongoing fuel cost – Propane tanks need to be refilled or replaced regularly
• Less heat output – Generally burns cooler than a wood fire
• Tank management – You'll need to keep spare tanks on hand to avoid running out
• Higher upfront cost – Propane models with burners and lava rocks tend to cost more
• Less ambiance – The flame, while beautiful, lacks the natural crackle and scent of wood

Side-by-Side Comparison

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose a wood burning fire pit if: You love the traditional campfire experience, want maximum heat output, or plan to use your fire pit in remote or off-grid settings.

Choose a propane fire pit if: You value convenience, live in an area with burn restrictions, want a cleaner setup, or prefer a low-maintenance backyard feature.

Still not sure? Browse our full selection of wood burning and propane fire pits and find the perfect fit for your outdoor space. Have questions? Our team is happy to help!